So is this average-average, a little more average than not, or what?

"Average" is such a vague term. Unless you're Scott, who measures it for a living.

You Are 60% "Average American"

You are average because you've known your best friend for at least ten years. You are not average since you don't think affirmative action is necessary.

How "Average American" Are You?

A/T to the never-average Miss Cellania.